 Paul NewmanThe Star (William F. Cody) | The Star (William F. Cody) |
 Joel GreyThe Producer (Nate Salisbury) | The Producer (Nate Salisbury) |
 Kevin McCarthyThe Publicist (Maj. John Burke) | The Publicist (Maj. John Burke) |
 Harvey KeitelThe Relative (Ed Goodman) | The Relative (Ed Goodman) |
 Allan F. NichollsThe Journalist (Prentiss Ingraham) | The Journalist (Prentiss Ingraham) |
 Geraldine ChaplinThe Sure Shot (Annie Oakley) | The Sure Shot (Annie Oakley) |
 John ConsidineThe Sure Shot's Manager (Frank Butler) | The Sure Shot's Manager (Frank Butler) |
 Robert DoQuiThe Wrangler (Oswald Dart) | The Wrangler (Oswald Dart) |
| MMike KaplanThe Treasurer (Jules Keen) | The Treasurer (Jules Keen) |
 Bert RemsenThe Bartender (Crutch) | The Bartender (Crutch) |
| BBonnie LeadersThe Mezzo-Contralto (Margaret) | The Mezzo-Contralto (Margaret) |
| NNoelle RogersThe Lyric-Coloratura (Lucille DuCharme) | The Lyric-Coloratura (Lucille DuCharme) |
| EEvelyn LearThe Lyric-Soprano (Nina Cavallini) | The Lyric-Soprano (Nina Cavallini) |
 Denver PyleThe Indian Agent (McLaughlin) | The Indian Agent (McLaughlin) |
| FFrank KaquittsThe Indian (Sitting Bull) | The Indian (Sitting Bull) |
 Will SampsonThe Interpreter (William Halsey) | The Interpreter (William Halsey) |
| KKen KrossaThe Arenic Director (Johnny Baker) | The Arenic Director (Johnny Baker) |
| FFred N. LarsenThe King of the Cowboys (Buck Taylor) | The King of the Cowboys (Buck Taylor) |
| JJerri DuceTrick Rider | Trick Rider |
| JJoy DuceTrick Rider | Trick Rider |
 Alex GreenWhip & Fast Draw Act | Whip & Fast Draw Act |
| GGary MacKenzieWhip & Fast Draw Act | Whip & Fast Draw Act |
| HHumphrey GratzOld Soldier | Old Soldier |
 Pat McCormickThe President of the United States (Grover Cleveland) | The President of the United States (Grover Cleveland) |
 Shelley DuvallThe First Lady (Mrs. Cleveland) | The First Lady (Mrs. Cleveland) |
 Burt LancasterThe Legend Maker (Ned Buntline) | The Legend Maker (Ned Buntline) |
| EE. L. DoctorowPresident Cleveland's Adviser (uncredited) | President Cleveland's Adviser (uncredited) |
 Patrick ReynoldsPresident Cleveland's Aide (uncredited) | President Cleveland's Aide (uncredited) |
