"Broncho Billy and the Schoolmistress" (1912, 14 minutes) is a comedy-drama about yet another girl from the East who doesn't need to be protected from the local dangers. Broncho Billy plays a passive role, and even takes a bullet when a jealous villain tries to eliminate him from the new teacher's dance card. Filmed in the wilds of Fairfax, California and at Essanay Studios in San Rafael.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Gilbert M. AndersonBroncho Billy | Broncho Billy |
 Brinsley ShawBilly's Rival | Billy's Rival |
 Augustus CarneyAlkali Ike | Alkali Ike |
| AArthur MackleyStage Driver / Doctor | Stage Driver / Doctor |
 Fred ChurchNot listed | Not listed |
 R. Henry GreyNot listed | Not listed |
| LLouis MorisetteNot listed | Not listed |
 Victor PotelNot listed | Not listed |
 Harry ToddNot listed | Not listed |