After being stood up, Abbey gets inspired to open her heart in a letter, put it in a bottle and toss it out to sea. Months later, a man fishing discovers it and opts to reach out.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Bethany Joy LenzAbbey Lawrence | Abbey Lawrence |
 Andrew W. WalkerNick Everson | Nick Everson |
 Kate IsaacSophie Everson | Sophie Everson |
 Bethany BrownElaine | Elaine |
 Frances FlanaganAunt Frances | Aunt Frances |
 Everick GoldingGeorge Wilmore | George Wilmore |
 Kevin McNultyEarl Everson | Earl Everson |
 Roman PodhoraStan Tucker | Stan Tucker |
 Eric GustafssonKevin | Kevin |
 Jill MorrisonCharlie | Charlie |
 Amanda WongKat | Kat |
 Elinet LouiciusGroom | Groom |
 Stephanie ChoDierdre | Dierdre |
 Ronald Patrick ThompsonOfficiant | Officiant |
 Garrett BlackWaiter | Waiter |
 Denis CorbettPasserby (uncredited) | Passerby (uncredited) |
 Yolanda CorbettPasserby (uncredited) | Passerby (uncredited) |