 Martin LandauJoseph Bonanno, age 94 | Joseph Bonanno, age 94 |
 Guido Grasso Jr.Peter Maggadino | Peter Maggadino |
 Bruce RamsayJoseph Bonanno (Ages 17-27) | Joseph Bonanno (Ages 17-27) |
 Tony NardiJoseph Bonanno (Ages 35-61) | Joseph Bonanno (Ages 35-61) |
 Costas MandylorSalvatore Bonanno | Salvatore Bonanno |
 Edward James OlmosSalvatore Maranzano | Salvatore Maranzano |
| VVito DeFilippoGaspar DiGregario (Young) | Gaspar DiGregario (Young) |
 Domenico FioreGaspar DiGregario (Older) | Gaspar DiGregario (Older) |
 Zachary BennettBill Bonanno | Bill Bonanno |
| AAldo TirelliBastiano Buster Domingo | Bastiano Buster Domingo |
 Claudia FerriFanny Labruzzo (Older) | Fanny Labruzzo (Older) |
| AAntonio MalteseItalian Naval Cadet | Italian Naval Cadet |
 Vito RezzaUncle Frank Labruzzo | Uncle Frank Labruzzo |
 Vince CorazzaCharlie 'Lucky' Luciano | Charlie 'Lucky' Luciano |
 Patti LuPoneMiss C. Canzinarra | Miss C. Canzinarra |
 Robert LoggiaDon Ciccio | Don Ciccio |
 Michael A. MirandaJoe Profaci(as Silvio Oliviero) | Joe Profaci(as Silvio Oliviero) |
 Philip BoscoSteve Maggadino Sr. | Steve Maggadino Sr. |
 Maurizio TerrazzanoAlbert Anastasia (Young) | Albert Anastasia (Young) |
 Frank CrudeleAlbert Anastasia (Older) | Albert Anastasia (Older) |
 Daniel PilonNot listed | Not listed |
 Jean-Pierre BergeronNot listed | Not listed |
 Ben BassNot listed | Not listed |
 Daniel KashNot listed | Not listed |
 Chuck ShamataSanto Trafficante | Santo Trafficante |
| JJoe De PaulCarlos Marcello | Carlos Marcello |
 Roger DunnNot listed | Not listed |
 Doug MurrayNot listed | Not listed |
 Frank PellegrinoJohn Tartamella | John Tartamella |
| JJessica WelchFanny Labruzzo(young) | Fanny Labruzzo(young) |
