A young man must find his own way as his Southern Baptist roots don't seem to be acceptable at his new liberal arts college.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Marshall AllmanDonald Miller | Donald Miller |
 Claire HoltPenny | Penny |
 Tania RaymondeLauryn | Lauryn |
 Justin WelbornThe Pope | The Pope |
 Eric LangeThe Hobo | The Hobo |
 Jason MarsdenKenny | Kenny |
| WWilliam McKinneyJordan | Jordan |
 Barak HardleyTown Crier | Town Crier |
 Valerie Jane ParkerAqualike Babe | Aqualike Babe |
 Susan IsaacsFan | Fan |
 Natalia DyerGrace | Grace |