 Kyle MacChristian | Christian |
| MMandy AldridgeAnnabelle (segment "We Once Were Tide") | Annabelle (segment "We Once Were Tide") |
 Daniel ArmandoSal (segment "Boys Like You") | Sal (segment "Boys Like You") |
 Crystal ArnetteSophie (segment: "Requited") | Sophie (segment: "Requited") |
| SSal BardoPaul (segment: "Requited") | Paul (segment: "Requited") |
| TTristan BernaysKyle (segment "We Once Were Tide") | Kyle (segment "We Once Were Tide") |
 Chris DamonNicolas (segment: "Requited") (as Christopher Schram) | Nicolas (segment: "Requited") (as Christopher Schram) |
 Tanya EverettThe Woman (segment "Boys Like You") | The Woman (segment "Boys Like You") |
 Dee HerlihyLaura (segment "Boys Like You") | Laura (segment "Boys Like You") |
| SStephen LundbergJimmy (segment "Boys Like You") (as Steven Lundberg) | Jimmy (segment "Boys Like You") (as Steven Lundberg) |
 Busy PhilippsEmily (segment: "Revolution") | Emily (segment: "Revolution") |
 Max RhyserGregor (segment: "Requited") | Gregor (segment: "Requited") |
| AAlexander ScottAnthony (Segment "We Once Were Tide") | Anthony (Segment "We Once Were Tide") |
| MMatthew WatsonAaron (segment: "Requited") | Aaron (segment: "Requited") |
