 Tyrone PowerJuan | Juan |
 Linda DarnellCarmen Espinosa | Carmen Espinosa |
 Rita HayworthDona Sol | Dona Sol |
 Alla NazimovaSenora Augustias | Senora Augustias |
 Anthony QuinnManolo de Palma | Manolo de Palma |
 J. Carrol NaishGarabato | Garabato |
 Lynn BariEncarnacion | Encarnacion |
 John CarradineNacional | Nacional |
 Laird CregarNatalio Curro | Natalio Curro |
 Monty BanksAntonio Lopez | Antonio Lopez |
 George ReevesCapt. Pierre Lauren | Capt. Pierre Lauren |
 Pedro de CordobaDon Jose Alvarez | Don Jose Alvarez |
 Fortunio BonanovaPedro Espinosa | Pedro Espinosa |
 Victor KilianPriest | Priest |
 Adrian MorrisLa Pulga | La Pulga |
 Ann E. ToddCarmen (as a child) | Carmen (as a child) |
 Cora Sue CollinsEncarnacion (as a child) | Encarnacion (as a child) |
 Russell HicksMarquis | Marquis |
 Maurice CassEl Milquetoast | El Milquetoast |
 Jacqueline DalyaGachi | Gachi |
 Rex DowningJuan (as a child) | Juan (as a child) |
| VVicente GómezGuitarist | Guitarist |
 Charles StevensPablo Gomez | Pablo Gomez |
| JJohn WallaceFrancisco | Francisco |
| CCullen JohnsonManolo (as a child) | Manolo (as a child) |
| LLarry HarrisPablo (as a child) | Pablo (as a child) |
| TTed FryeLa Pulga (as a child) | La Pulga (as a child) |
| SSchuyler StandishNacional (as a child) | Nacional (as a child) |
 Rafael AlcaydeUndetermined Role (uncredited) | Undetermined Role (uncredited) |
 Harry BurnsTrain Engineer (uncredited) | Train Engineer (uncredited) |
