A drama teacher's taboo relationship with an unstable student strikes a nerve in her jealous classmate, sparking a vengeful chain of events within their suburban high school that draws parallels to "The Crucible".
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Quinn ShephardAbigail | Abigail |
 Nadia AlexanderMelissa | Melissa |
 Trieste Kelly DunnJennifer | Jennifer |
 Marcia DeBonisMs. Cohen | Ms. Cohen |
 Tessa AlbertsonEllie | Ellie |
 Sarah MezzanotteSophie | Sophie |
 Owen CampbellTJ | TJ |
 Luke SlatteryEric | Eric |
 Tate DonovanRobert | Robert |
 Chris MessinaJeremy Woods | Jeremy Woods |
| EElizabeth HowellAbigail's Mother | Abigail's Mother |
| CCarlyle OwensAbigail's Father | Abigail's Father |
 Geneva CarrMrs. Howell | Mrs. Howell |
| WWhitney HarrisMelissa's mother (voice) | Melissa's mother (voice) |
| LLily HoughtonLily / Drama Student | Lily / Drama Student |
| PPhelan TupikPhelan / Drama Student | Phelan / Drama Student |
| MMichael JeffersonHallway Teacher | Hallway Teacher |
 Larry MitchellOfficer Dolan | Officer Dolan |
| JJulie DwoskinDrama Student | Drama Student |
| SSherilyn JamesDrama Student | Drama Student |
| JJack LabbeDrama Student | Drama Student |
| AAshley La SelvaDrama Student | Drama Student |
| MMichelle MartinezDrama Student | Drama Student |