 Christopher ReeveAlan Johnson | Alan Johnson |
 Raoul Max TrujilloRunning Dog | Running Dog |
 Tony ToddBritt Johnson (Black Fox) | Britt Johnson (Black Fox) |
 Janet BaileyMary Johnson | Mary Johnson |
 Nancy SorelSarah Johnson | Sarah Johnson |
 Chris WigginsRalph Holtz | Ralph Holtz |
| CChris BensonNot listed | Not listed |
 Lawrence DaneColonel McKensie | Colonel McKensie |
 Cynthia PrestonDelores Holtz / Morning Star (as Cyndy Preston) | Delores Holtz / Morning Star (as Cyndy Preston) |
 Dale WilsonNot listed | Not listed |
| LLeon GoodstrikerLittle Buffalo | Little Buffalo |
| MMorningstar MercrediTalking Raven | Talking Raven |
| JJoel Phage-WrightNot listed | Not listed |
 Don S. DavisNot listed | Not listed |
 Byron Chief-MoonStanding Bear (as Byron Chief Moon) | Standing Bear (as Byron Chief Moon) |
 Buffalo ChildNot listed | Not listed |
| DDenis LacroixLone Wolf | Lone Wolf |
 Marty ChiefcalfWarrior (uncredited) | Warrior (uncredited) |
 Lorette ClowMaggie Bragg (uncredited) | Maggie Bragg (uncredited) |
| PPat JohnstonGrady Bragg (uncredited) | Grady Bragg (uncredited) |
 David LeReaneyCavalry Officer (uncredited) | Cavalry Officer (uncredited) |
| CCharles SansRev. Tom Smith (uncredited) | Rev. Tom Smith (uncredited) |
