 Katie CassidyKelli Presley | Kelli Presley |
 Michelle TrachtenbergMelissa Kitt | Melissa Kitt |
 Mary Elizabeth WinsteadHeather Fitzgerald | Heather Fitzgerald |
 Lacey ChabertDana Mathis | Dana Mathis |
 Oliver HudsonKyle Autry | Kyle Autry |
 Kristen ClokeLeigh Colvin | Leigh Colvin |
 Andrea MartinBarbara 'Ms. Mac' MacHenry | Barbara 'Ms. Mac' MacHenry |
 Yan-Kay Crystal LoweLauren Hannon | Lauren Hannon |
 Karin KonovalBilly's Mother | Billy's Mother |
 Robert MannBilly Lenz - 20 & 35 Years | Billy Lenz - 20 & 35 Years |
| DDean FrissAgnes - 16 & 22 Years | Agnes - 16 & 22 Years |
 Jessica HarmonMegan Helms | Megan Helms |
 Leela SavastaClair Crosby | Clair Crosby |
 Cainan WiebeBilly Lenz - 5 & 12 Years | Billy Lenz - 5 & 12 Years |
 Christina CriviciAgnes - 8 Years | Agnes - 8 Years |
 Kathleen KoleEve Agnew | Eve Agnew |
 Howard SiegelLover / Stepfather | Lover / Stepfather |
| PPeter WildsFrank Lenz | Frank Lenz |
 Ron SelmourSecurity Guard | Security Guard |
 Michael AdamthwaiteSanta | Santa |
 Peter NewSanitarium Orderly | Sanitarium Orderly |
 Christian SloanRichard Steinmetz | Richard Steinmetz |
 Alycia PurrottCandy Striper | Candy Striper |
 Juan RiedingerMorgue Attendant | Morgue Attendant |
 Aaron PearlBludworth | Bludworth |
 Peggy LoganNurse | Nurse |
 Jill TeedNews Reporter | News Reporter |
 Peggy Jo JacobsWeathergirl | Weathergirl |
 Jerry WassermanMedical Examiner | Medical Examiner |
| DDerek McIverOrderly | Orderly |
