The Fibbler makes a fiendish plan to break up the group. He starts with Ashley, coercing her into lying to the rest of her friends. Bibleman comes by to check on them, but he senses something sinister.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Willie AamesBibleman / Miles Peterson | Bibleman / Miles Peterson |
| BBill MurphyThe Fibbler | The Fibbler |
| CCallie DyeCalli | Calli |
| NNatasha SmithNikki | Nikki |
| AAshley PerryAshley | Ashley |
| RRoman SienkiewiczRickey | Rickey |
| JJoe CarrRyan | Ryan |