With Miles Peterson enjoying his retirement, Cypher, Biblegirl, and U.N.I.C.E are introduced to their new team member, Josh Carpenter—the new Bibleman! Not to be outdone by a new Bibleman, the Wacky Protestor formulates a plan to not only re-invent himself, but to create a world where there will be no Christians, no churches, no Bibles, and no God!
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| RRobert T. SchlippBibleman / Josh Carpenter | Bibleman / Josh Carpenter |
 Brady WilliamsCypher | Cypher |
| JJef ScottWacky Protestor / Rotten Guy | Wacky Protestor / Rotten Guy |
| HHeather McSmithBiblegirl | Biblegirl |
| RRyan StathosGabriel Phillips | Gabriel Phillips |
| RRoxanne StathosOlivia Phillips | Olivia Phillips |