The unsettling true story of America's first serial-killing family. A troubled doctor searches for patients swallowed by the prairie and encounters the Benders, homesteaders trapped by a life of unspeakable sin.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Bruce DavisonMayor Prentiss | Mayor Prentiss |
 Linda PurlMrs. Thomas | Mrs. Thomas |
 James KarenOld Man Bender | Old Man Bender |
 Buck TaylorSheriff J.E. Stone | Sheriff J.E. Stone |
| JJohn MonasteroDr. William York / Edwin York | Dr. William York / Edwin York |
| NNicole JellenKate Bender | Kate Bender |
 Reylynn CasterLittle Girl | Little Girl |
| LLeslie WoodiesOld Woman Bender | Old Woman Bender |
| GGrace McKeaneyGoat Lady | Goat Lady |
 Chance CaedenBoy | Boy |
| PPreston BrownMr. Loncher | Mr. Loncher |
| BBrad FieldsParson | Parson |
| CCat OlsonEthel | Ethel |
| HHannah RikoonMrs. Loncher | Mrs. Loncher |