A small-town business owner tries to save the local Christmas pageant against all odds.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Ryan O'QuinnMatthew Peyton | Matthew Peyton |
 Shawnee SmithDr. Nancy Wells | Dr. Nancy Wells |
 Danielle NicoletSharon Joseph | Sharon Joseph |
 Kevin SizemoreAlbert Bagley | Albert Bagley |
 David DeLuiseTom Blackhorn | Tom Blackhorn |
 Issac Ryan BrownClarence Joseph | Clarence Joseph |
 Lance E. NicholsMayor Harris | Mayor Harris |
 James C. BurnsBob Alexander | Bob Alexander |
| SScott SummittCharlie | Charlie |
 Joey NaberNick | Nick |
 Bryce LenonSam | Sam |
 Gunnar SizemoreCollin | Collin |
 David SchifterWendell | Wendell |
 Meredith JacksonWoman #2 | Woman #2 |