| KKeishaun Jonesself | self |
| BBernarda Villalonaself - criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor | self - criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor |
| BBrian Buckmireself - legal analyst, Law & Crime | self - legal analyst, Law & Crime |
| KKirk Burkhalterself - former detective/law professor | self - former detective/law professor |
| CChristopher Loweself - | self - |
| SSebastian Jean Jacquesself - murder victim | self - murder victim |
| TTravis Rudolphself - former NFL player, murder suspect | self - former NFL player, murder suspect |
| TTerri Austinself - legal analyst, Law & Crime | self - legal analyst, Law & Crime |
| TTyler Robinsonself - shooting victim | self - shooting victim |
| DDominique Jonesself - Travis Rudolph's ex-girlfriend | self - Travis Rudolph's ex-girlfriend |
| DDetective Emily Vänder-Laanself - detective, Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office | self - detective, Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office |
| MMarc Shinerself - Travis Rudolph's defense attorney | self - Travis Rudolph's defense attorney |
| DDarryl Rudolphself - Travis Rudolph's brother | self - Travis Rudolph's brother |
