CEO of the Morton Pumpkin Company decides to commemorate the 200th anniversary of the cutest town ever founded with a bake-off. The town sweetheart is expected to win. When her niece is left to stay, winning seems out of reach.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| MMark BischoffLulu's On Main Customer | Lulu's On Main Customer |
| AAlix KermesLynn Travis | Lynn Travis |
 Michael BoniniPeter Menold | Peter Menold |
 Jason FrederickPierce Morton | Pierce Morton |
 Catherine CainJulie Remington | Julie Remington |
 Stefanie BloomMadison Bell | Madison Bell |
 David OtungaCoach Robinson | Coach Robinson |
| AAllison GrischowLulu Davis | Lulu Davis |
 Kenney MyersMayor Jeff Kaufman | Mayor Jeff Kaufman |
 Katelin StackMae Kaufman | Mae Kaufman |
 Jeff TimmonsPastor Mark | Pastor Mark |
 Ivana GrahovacBrooke Remington | Brooke Remington |
| CCollin WeigleBake-Off Attendee | Bake-Off Attendee |
| AAdam SmithLulu's On Main Customer | Lulu's On Main Customer |
| JJames JulahBake-Off Attendee | Bake-Off Attendee |
| PPeter GrantBake-Off Attendee | Bake-Off Attendee |