"Bailey's Mistake" is the name of a cold, dreary island that a bitter widow finds herself stuck on. Seems Liz Donovan got cut out of her husband's will because he'd secretly spent all his money on a New England island. Kids in tow, Liz discovers spooky secrets while getting to know the eccentric natives.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Linda HamiltonLiz Donovan | Liz Donovan |
 Kyle SecorLowell Lenox | Lowell Lenox |
 Jesse JamesDylan Donovan | Dylan Donovan |
 Paz de la HuertaBecca Donovan | Becca Donovan |
 Richard BurgiPaul Donovan | Paul Donovan |
 Joan PlowrightAunt Angie | Aunt Angie |
 Kris LemcheMalachy | Malachy |
 David NoronaFather Miguel | Father Miguel |
 Jeremy AkermanOld Salt | Old Salt |
 Julianne ChristieJasmine | Jasmine |
 Dawn GreenhalghIrene | Irene |
| JJefferson MappinToby | Toby |
 Leslie CarlsonStableman | Stableman |
 Peter BlaisCharlie | Charlie |
 Nicola LipmanGina | Gina |
| BBernie WallworthOld Salt's Mother | Old Salt's Mother |
 Deborah AllenHousekeeper | Housekeeper |
| TTyler ReginatoYoung Paul | Young Paul |
| BBruce ArmstrongAl | Al |
 John Marshall JonesTyler | Tyler |