Pat Garrett arrives in Abilene where he catches five of Butch Cassidy's gang. He calls in Wyatt Earp and Bat Masterson and they learn there is a half million dollar shipment of money arriving by train and Cassidy is amassing enough men to take it.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 George MontgomeryPat Garrett | Pat Garrett |
 Neville BrandButch Cassidy | Butch Cassidy |
 Buster CrabbeWyatt Earp | Wyatt Earp |
 Karin BoothLorna | Lorna |
 Gregory WalcottBat Masterson | Bat Masterson |
 Malcolm AtterburyBuffalo Bill Cody | Buffalo Bill Cody |
 Russell JohnsonSundance | Sundance |
 Richard DevonHarvey Logan | Harvey Logan |
 Morris AnkrumMayor Coleman | Mayor Coleman |
 Dan RissMarshal McAfee | Marshal McAfee |
| MMartin BenedictYoung Boy (uncredited) | Young Boy (uncredited) |