 Jeff BridgesFather Daniel Flynn / Dock O'Kelly | Father Daniel Flynn / Dock O'Kelly |
 Cynthia ErivoDarlene Sweet | Darlene Sweet |
 Lewis PullmanMiles Miller | Miles Miller |
 Dakota JohnsonEmily Summerspring | Emily Summerspring |
 Cailee SpaenyRose Summerspring | Rose Summerspring |
 Jon HammLaramie Seymour Sullivan / Dwight Broadbeck | Laramie Seymour Sullivan / Dwight Broadbeck |
 Chris HemsworthBilly Lee | Billy Lee |
 Nick OffermanFelix O'Kelly | Felix O'Kelly |
 Xavier DolanBuddy Sunday | Buddy Sunday |
 Shea WhighamDr. Woodbury Laurence | Dr. Woodbury Laurence |
 Mark O'BrienLarsen Rogers | Larsen Rogers |
 Charles HalfordSammy Wilds | Sammy Wilds |
 Jim O'HeirMilton Wyrick | Milton Wyrick |
 Gerry NairnReporter Paul Kraemer | Reporter Paul Kraemer |
 Alvina AugustVesta Shears | Vesta Shears |
 London MorrisonAngela Harris, Vesta's Backup Singer | Angela Harris, Vesta's Backup Singer |
 Bethany BrownFlorence Lemons, Vesta's Backup Singer | Florence Lemons, Vesta's Backup Singer |
 Rebecca ToolanHelen Gandy | Helen Gandy |
 Hannah ZirkeYoung Emily Summerspring | Young Emily Summerspring |
 Billy WickmanHutch Summerspring | Hutch Summerspring |
| CCharlotte MosbyYoung Rose Summerspring | Young Rose Summerspring |
 William B. DavisJudge Gordon Hoffman | Judge Gordon Hoffman |
 Manny JacintoWaring 'Wade' Espiritu | Waring 'Wade' Espiritu |
 Tally RodinSilvana 'Millie' Melvin | Silvana 'Millie' Melvin |
 Sophia Lauchlin HirtAnnabell Czuchlewski | Annabell Czuchlewski |
 Jonathan WhitesellChris 'Flicker' Grimes | Chris 'Flicker' Grimes |
 Synto D. MisatiNorris 'Roman' Kindel | Norris 'Roman' Kindel |
 Austin A.J. AbellYoung Miles Miller | Young Miles Miller |
 Katharine IsabelleAuntie Ruth Pugh | Auntie Ruth Pugh |
 Sarah SmythGinger Miller | Ginger Miller |
