Married couple Bob and Susan Howard decide to see a marriage counselor named Judy Small, who appears trustworthy but harbors dark and conflicted impulses.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Michaela WatkinsJudy Small | Judy Small |
 Alicia SilverstoneSusan Howard | Susan Howard |
 Rob CorddryBob Howard | Bob Howard |
 Anna PniowskyLouise | Louise |
 David PaymerDr. Edward Kingsley | Dr. Edward Kingsley |
 Aisha TylerRoxy | Roxy |
 Sarah ShahiAnnabelle | Annabelle |
 Haley Joel OsmentReed | Reed |
 Dichen LachmanStern | Stern |
 John Ross BowieNick | Nick |
 Ginger GonzagaMiranda | Miranda |
 Sunkrish BalaWalter | Walter |
 Erik GriffinPrincipal Sykes | Principal Sykes |
 Paris BravoZooey | Zooey |
 Angela OhDr. Smithson | Dr. Smithson |
 Marcelo TubertDr. John | Dr. John |
 Jack AxelrodDr. Cherbenko | Dr. Cherbenko |
 Brett HoyleJames | James |
 Flula BorgSerge | Serge |
| CCraig Robert YoungRoger | Roger |
 Gavin LeatherwoodSpit | Spit |
 Chido NwokochaPoliceman | Policeman |