On Halloween night in New Salem, Radio DJs Chilly Billy and Paul tell a twisted anthology of terrifying local myths. Residents of the small-town experience horrifying paranormal encounters that lead them to a grim end.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Zach GalliganPaul | Paul |
 Corey TaylorChilly Billy | Chilly Billy |
 Derek RussoVince | Vince |
 Brittney RaeKat | Kat |
 Haley LearyAbbie | Abbie |
 Kevin WayneGreg | Greg |
 Alexandra LucchesiMarie | Marie |
 Audrey WilliamsParty Attendee | Party Attendee |
 Michael Aaron MilliganChuck | Chuck |
 Kenneth TrujilloDaryl | Daryl |
 Tara DiPetrilloHooker #1 | Hooker #1 |
 Samantha Noel Van SickleVanessa | Vanessa |
 J. Gaven WildeJacob | Jacob |
 Natalia NovaAlexandria | Alexandria |
 John Wilkins IIIJohn Smith | John Smith |
 Michael WhinnettTim | Tim |
 Tordy ClarkJudy | Judy |
 Dallas T. TaylorMasked Man | Masked Man |
 Riley SuttonKyra | Kyra |
 David WalterhouseJimmy | Jimmy |
 Ryan KiserCharlie | Charlie |
 Nilah BlasingameSara | Sara |
 Bill PacerMr. Grimsley | Mr. Grimsley |
 Bradley NnadiCurtis | Curtis |
 Chris MayersCustomer | Customer |
 Jeff G. MungaiPumpkin Head | Pumpkin Head |
| CCameron ShermanFlasher / Main Pumpkin Head | Flasher / Main Pumpkin Head |
| EElena GoodrowDes | Des |
 Shmiddy SchmidtCreature | Creature |
 Jay PlyburnScotti | Scotti |