Six years after an affair with the 15-year old daughter of the priest who was his mentor, a former youth minister, now an ex-con and recovering addict, returns to his hometown seeking redemption, only to find that his past will not let him go.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Alicia WittLily | Lily |
 Nick StahlJames | James |
 Ray WisePaul | Paul |
 Frankie FaisonCarl | Carl |
 John Bedford LloydJon | Jon |
 Peter ConboyPainter | Painter |
 Cosondra SjostromDiner Local | Diner Local |
| Cosondra SjostromBig Guy in Hallway | Big Guy in Hallway |
 Donna MitchellRachel | Rachel |
 Julie GarfieldPhoebe | Phoebe |
 Mary Regency BoiesJessica | Jessica |
 Marisa RedantyWoman | Woman |
| LLaura BeckettWaitress | Waitress |
 Ray WiederholdOfficer Potter | Officer Potter |
| MMichelle E. ManciniBible Class Teen | Bible Class Teen |