When a priceless crown is stolen during a benefit gala held by the Lawrenceton library, Aurora and the Real Murders Club must investigate who would kill to get their hands on it.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Candace Cameron BureAurora Teagarden | Aurora Teagarden |
 Niall MatterNick Miller | Nick Miller |
 Marilu HennerAida Teagarden | Aida Teagarden |
 Lexa DoigSally Allison | Sally Allison |
 Peter BensonArthur Smith | Arthur Smith |
 Miranda FrigonLynn Smith | Lynn Smith |
 Dylan SloanePhillip Pifer | Phillip Pifer |
 Ellie HarvieLillian Tibbett | Lillian Tibbett |
 Brendon ZubEric Hanson | Eric Hanson |
 Oliver RiceJames Reading | James Reading |
 Michelle HarrisonKelly Stevens | Kelly Stevens |
 Elfina LukMiya Quan | Miya Quan |
 Chris GauthierHoward Kane | Howard Kane |
 Catherine Lough HaggquistTerry Sternholz | Terry Sternholz |
 Cole VigueDavis Mettle | Davis Mettle |
 Sean DepnerBrett Talbot | Brett Talbot |
 Jay HindleDavid Reyes | David Reyes |
 Lisa Marie DiGiacintoCallie Reyes | Callie Reyes |
| BByron MayberryLeo Stevens | Leo Stevens |
 Ellen EwusieLawyer Julia | Lawyer Julia |
| FForbes AngusJewelry Shop Owner | Jewelry Shop Owner |
 Shaw MadsonSecurity Guard | Security Guard |