A chance encounter on Valentine's Day brings Hannah and Finn together as they race through New York City to return a lost engagement ring and save one couple's special day.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lacey ChabertHannah | Hannah |
 Robert BuckleyFinn | Finn |
 Jess BrownGabby | Gabby |
 Princess DavisNadine | Nadine |
 Anthony TimpanoNate | Nate |
 Caitlin StrykerAnnalisa | Annalisa |
 Vincent TongLevi | Levi |
 Sergio OsunaJuan | Juan |
| CChelsea BrownAmelie | Amelie |
 Madeleine KeldersVera | Vera |
 Kaniel Jacob-CrossLittle Mikey | Little Mikey |
 Marion EismanJudy | Judy |
 Liza HugetInstructor | Instructor |
 Linden BanksCliff | Cliff |
 Marco SorianoMario | Mario |
| MMarco Walker-NgMan | Man |
 Hannah HenneyWoman | Woman |
| RRichard Elias AndersonBouncer | Bouncer |
| MMiles MeadowsFlorist | Florist |
 Britney MoccaPasserby | Passerby |
 Viv LeacockArthur | Arthur |
| MMariela ZapataArt Class Model | Art Class Model |
 Matt ClarkeNYC Police Officer | NYC Police Officer |