The Overplayed Music Police reunite in a mega sketch comedy special focused on the greatest Christmas song of all-time. Mariah we love you.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Will F YoungWill | Will |
 Dov Lebowitz-NowakDov | Dov |
 Amber BloomNot listed | Not listed |
 Mariah CareyMariah | Mariah |
 Christopher CoakleyJust Chris. | Just Chris. |
 Kimberly DiPersiaKim | Kim |
 Pagie WilsonPagie | Pagie |
| KKatharine AriyanKate | Kate |
| MMarine AssaianteMarine | Marine |
| AAmy SoraghanAmy | Amy |
| HHelene GalekHelene | Helene |
| MMcKylin RoweBittuh Pupil | Bittuh Pupil |
| RRita SanchesRita | Rita |
| JJulia St. PierreJulia | Julia |
| CClaire ThompsonClaire | Claire |
| MMercedez YasmeenMercedez | Mercedez |