This sensational true story of a near fatal attraction left Mary Jo Buttafuoco paralyzed for life and made Amy Fisher America's most infamous teenager. Imprisoned 5-15 years for a crime she confessed to Fisher has nothing to lose by telling how it was-her way, her story. Deception, Promiscuous Sex, and Violence
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Ed MarinaroJoey Buttafuoco | Joey Buttafuoco |
 Noelle ParkerAmy Fisher | Amy Fisher |
 Boyd KestnerPaul Makely | Paul Makely |
| PPierrette GraceCrystal | Crystal |
 Lawrence DaneElliot Fisher | Elliot Fisher |
 Kate LynchRoseann Fisher | Roseann Fisher |
| KKathleen LaskeyMary Jo Buttafuoco | Mary Jo Buttafuoco |
 Rino RomanoMick | Mick |
| GGemma BarryTheresa | Theresa |
| KKirsten KieferleEllen | Ellen |
 Henriette IvanansDarlene | Darlene |
| EEvan SabbaStudent | Student |
| MMarianna PascalAunt Violet | Aunt Violet |
| AAngelo PedariBar Friend #1 | Bar Friend #1 |
 Brian KaulbackBar Friend #2 | Bar Friend #2 |
| JJ. Winston CarrollJohn #1 | John #1 |