Explores the controversy surrounding the supposed haunting of Amityville's most famous house.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 David AckroydNarrator (Voice) | Narrator (Voice) |
 Arthur KentHimself (Host) | Himself (Host) |
| GGeorge LutzHimeself | Himeself |
| GGeorge LutzHimself | Himself |
| KKathy LutzHerself | Herself |
| LLaura DiDioHerself | Herself |
 Lorraine WarrenHerself | Herself |
| EEd WarrenHimself | Himself |
 Jay AnsonHimself (archive footage) | Himself (archive footage) |