 Sienna MillerDeb Callahan | Deb Callahan |
 Christina HendricksKath | Kath |
 Aaron PaulChris | Chris |
 Will SassoTerry | Terry |
 Sky FerreiraBridget Callahan | Bridget Callahan |
 Pat HealyRay | Ray |
 Alex NeustaedterTyler Hanrick | Tyler Hanrick |
 E. Roger MitchellDet. Sergeant Morris | Det. Sergeant Morris |
 Kentucker AudleyBrett Tobeck | Brett Tobeck |
 Aidan McGrawJesse (Age 7) | Jesse (Age 7) |
 Aidan FiskeJesse (Age 13) | Jesse (Age 13) |
 Amy MadiganPeggy | Peggy |
| AAlexander Joseph WildesJesse (Age 1) | Jesse (Age 1) |
| MMaximus Thomas WildesJesse (Age 1) | Jesse (Age 1) |
| KKatie ElinoffCindy | Cindy |
| RRene CadetPaul | Paul |
| GGavin EarleMurph (Age 10) | Murph (Age 10) |
| KKobi PoliskyPatrick (Age 8) | Patrick (Age 8) |
 Adrianne KrstanskyCarol Hanrick | Carol Hanrick |
 Kelly Rose GoldenJenna Cunningham | Jenna Cunningham |
 Bates WilderDetective O'Brien | Detective O'Brien |
| CChet HardingLocal News Reporter | Local News Reporter |
| GGwen CallahanMrs. Clancy | Mrs. Clancy |
| KKaren ElversonMrs. Caponi | Mrs. Caponi |
| RRosemary MahoneyMrs. Hastings | Mrs. Hastings |
 Maggie CastleBrett's Wife | Brett's Wife |
 Dennis StaroselskyProfessor Walters | Professor Walters |
| TTyler Wesley ParrishMurph (Age 16) | Murph (Age 16) |
 Jack BrunaultPatrick (Age 14) | Patrick (Age 14) |
 Maggie BudzynaColleen | Colleen |
