Desperate to see their church grow, Pastor John (Robert Amaya) and wife Betsy (Erin Bethea) do the unthinkable and change their church Christmas pageant. Flabbergasted, elderly choir director Mary Margaret (Sallie Wanchisn) leads the choir to boycott. Facing termination, Pastor John resorts to disguising himself as an old man to bridge the generation gap, win over Mary, and lead the choir back to the church. When he discovers that the wounds run deeper than he first suspected, Pastor John must learn to love the unlovable or risk the ruin of his church and family.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Robert AmayaPastor John | Pastor John |
| IIsabella AntinoriAudience Member | Audience Member |
| KKaylyn AznavorianMall Shoper | Mall Shoper |
| TThomas Lee BakerNorm Steedy (as Tom Baker) | Norm Steedy (as Tom Baker) |
| SSue BeanJudith | Judith |
 Erin BetheaBetsy | Betsy |
| AArielle BielickiMall Shopper | Mall Shopper |
| LLuke BlevinsHigh School Student | High School Student |
| AAsia ChristmasMall Shopper | Mall Shopper |
 Scotty CurleeBob Stern | Bob Stern |
| RRachel DarttSwim Instructor (as Rachel Dart) | Swim Instructor (as Rachel Dart) |
| DDaniel EllisCort | Cort |
| SSarah GlassHolly's friend | Holly's friend |
 Dot GregorySwim Fitness Member (Dottie) | Swim Fitness Member (Dottie) |
| LLilianna GriffeeCongregation Member | Congregation Member |
 Victoria JacksonBarbara | Barbara |
| DDevon KeyAudience Member | Audience Member |
| LLeland KlassenPendergrass | Pendergrass |
| MMax MorganJack | Jack |
 Bryson PittsSick Kid | Sick Kid |
 Alexander Vaughn MillerDirk | Dirk |