 Kirk DouglasMarshal Len Merrick | Marshal Len Merrick |
 Virginia MayoAnn Keith | Ann Keith |
 John AgarBilly Shear | Billy Shear |
 Walter BrennanTimothy 'Pop' Keith | Timothy 'Pop' Keith |
 Ray TealDeputy Lou Gray | Deputy Lou Gray |
 Hugh SandersFrank Newcombe | Frank Newcombe |
 Morris AnkrumEd Roden | Ed Roden |
 James AndersonDan Roden | Dan Roden |
 Charles MeredithJudge Marlow | Judge Marlow |
 Sam AshDefense Counsel (uncredited) | Defense Counsel (uncredited) |
 Bob BurnsJuror (uncredited) | Juror (uncredited) |
 Lane ChandlerSheriff (uncredited) | Sheriff (uncredited) |
 Steve ClarkWitness Weaver (uncredited) | Witness Weaver (uncredited) |
| RRussell CusterHanging Spectator (uncredited) | Hanging Spectator (uncredited) |
 Steve DarrellProsecutor (uncredited) | Prosecutor (uncredited) |
 Al FergusonBailiff (uncredited) | Bailiff (uncredited) |
| JJoe GarcioTrial Spectator (uncredited) | Trial Spectator (uncredited) |
| AAugie GomezTrial Spectator (uncredited) | Trial Spectator (uncredited) |
 Carl HarbaughJerome (uncredited) | Jerome (uncredited) |
| AAl HaskellJuror (uncredited) | Juror (uncredited) |
 Jack KennyHanging Spectator (uncredited) | Hanging Spectator (uncredited) |
| AAl KundeJuror (uncredited) | Juror (uncredited) |
 Kenneth MacDonaldCrowley (uncredited) | Crowley (uncredited) |
| JJack MontgomeryHangman (uncredited) | Hangman (uncredited) |
 Zon MurrayJake Wilson (uncredited) | Jake Wilson (uncredited) |
| JJack ParkerHanging Spectator (uncredited) | Hanging Spectator (uncredited) |
| JJim ReevesJuror (uncredited) | Juror (uncredited) |
| AAllen D. SewallTrial Spectator (uncredited) | Trial Spectator (uncredited) |
| LLucile SewallTrial Spectator (uncredited) | Trial Spectator (uncredited) |
 Guy WilkersonJury Foreman (uncredited) | Jury Foreman (uncredited) |
