 Katie MaguireSarah | Sarah |
 Catherine A. CallahanCaroline | Caroline |
 Marie MaserCostume Designer (archive footage) | Costume Designer (archive footage) |
 Kayla LianCasey (archive footage) | Casey (archive footage) |
 Mike GiannelliArt the Clown / Demon | Art the Clown / Demon |
 Sydney FreihoferTia | Tia |
 Cole MathewsonTimmy | Timmy |
 Michael ChmielJohn (voice) / Attendant (archive footage) | John (voice) / Attendant (archive footage) |
 Marissa WolfKristen | Kristen |
 Minna TaylorSara | Sara |
 Brandon deSpainAlien | Alien |
| DDaniel RodasMan in Car (archive footage) | Man in Car (archive footage) |
 Christine EvangelistaScarecrow | Scarecrow |
| AAnna MalierePregnant Woman (archive footage) | Pregnant Woman (archive footage) |
| EEric DiezSatan (archive footage) | Satan (archive footage) |
| JJennifer CastellanoMutilated Woman (archive footage) | Mutilated Woman (archive footage) |
| MMarc RomanoHobo (archive footage) | Hobo (archive footage) |
| AAndrew MahlerPig Man (archive footage) | Pig Man (archive footage) |
| SSteven MancusoBird Man (archive footage) | Bird Man (archive footage) |
| LLori Anne LovaglioWitch (archive footage) | Witch (archive footage) |
| JJohn Francis McCarthyScarecrow's Slave / Demon (archive footage) | Scarecrow's Slave / Demon (archive footage) |
 Robyn KerrDawn | Dawn |
| GGary LoSavioTalk Radio Host / Nick (archive footage) | Talk Radio Host / Nick (archive footage) |
| DDean BriscoeDemon (archive footage) | Demon (archive footage) |
