| AAndrea MonierWoman | Woman |
| DDamien MonierTrickster | Trickster |
 Griffin GluckMax (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) | Max (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) |
 Helen RogersElizabeth (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) | Elizabeth (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) |
| TTyler RossellJack (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) | Jack (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) |
| BBrazenOscar (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) | Oscar (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) |
| SSteve Anderson Jr.Elliott (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) | Elliott (segment "Jack Attack") (archive footage) |
| RRon BaschJack (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) | Jack (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) |
 Emily AlataloKate (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) | Kate (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) |
 Angela BesharahWary Woman (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) | Wary Woman (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) |
 Julian RichingsChatterbox (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) | Chatterbox (segment "The Last Halloween") (archive footage) |
| BBob JaffeFather (segment "The Offering") (archive footage) | Father (segment "The Offering") (archive footage) |
| JJared Mark SmithSon (segment "The Offering") (archive footage) | Son (segment "The Offering") (archive footage) |
 Anthony BackmanBrad (segment "Descent") (archive footage) | Brad (segment "Descent") (archive footage) |
 Renee IntlekoferVanessa (segment "Descent") (archive footage) | Vanessa (segment "Descent") (archive footage) |
| RRobert McLaughlinKiller (segment "Descent") (archive footage) | Killer (segment "Descent") (archive footage) |
| AApril AdamsonAndrea (segment "Descent") (archive footage) | Andrea (segment "Descent") (archive footage) |
 Bill Oberst Jr.Sade (segment "M is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Sade (segment "M is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
 Jonathan NationMasochist (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Masochist (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
| FFinn KoblerSam (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Sam (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
| ZZion HealyFat Pat (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Fat Pat (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
| RReno SelmserRick (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Rick (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
 Kalie AchesonFemale Masochist (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) | Female Masochist (segment "M Is for Masochist") (archive footage) |
 Christie Lynn SmithLoraine (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) | Loraine (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) |
 Brian MajesticFather (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) | Father (segment "A Boy's Life") (archive footage) |
| MMichael SerratoMr. Tricker (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) | Mr. Tricker (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) |
| CCarrie SeimMonica (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) | Monica (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) |
| JJames MarkidisP.J. (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) | P.J. (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) |
| PPatrick LogothettiDonnie (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) | Donnie (segment "Mr. Tricker's Treat") (archive footage) |
 Sergio BerónFranco (segment "Alexia") (archive footage) | Franco (segment "Alexia") (archive footage) |
