After a decade apart, Maggie tracks down her elusive father. His fixation with UFOs has intensified over the years, which frustrates her attempts to communicate some big news.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Dianna AgronMaggie | Maggie |
 Thomas Haden ChurchLloyd | Lloyd |
 Sameerah Luqmaan-HarrisCharlie | Charlie |
| MMiranda O'BrienYoung Maggie | Young Maggie |
| NNicholas ClaryBraces | Braces |
| BBarret O'BrienHunter | Hunter |
| WWillow Zoe EgdesSlam Dunk Tuesday (voice) | Slam Dunk Tuesday (voice) |
| MMigoMigo | Migo |