 Raymond MasseyAbe Lincoln | Abe Lincoln |
 Gene LockhartStephen Douglas | Stephen Douglas |
 Ruth GordonMary Todd Lincoln | Mary Todd Lincoln |
 Mary HowardAnn Rutledge | Ann Rutledge |
 Minor WatsonJoshua Speed | Joshua Speed |
 Alan BaxterBilly Herndon | Billy Herndon |
 Harvey StephensNinian Edwards | Ninian Edwards |
 Howard Da SilvaJack Armstrong | Jack Armstrong |
 Dorothy TreeElizabeth Edwards | Elizabeth Edwards |
 Aldrich BowkerJudge Bowling Green | Judge Bowling Green |
 Maurice MurphyJohn McNeil | John McNeil |
 Louis Jean HeydtMentor Graham | Mentor Graham |
 Clem BevansBen Mattling | Ben Mattling |
 Harlan BriggsDenton Offut | Denton Offut |
 Herbert RudleySeth Gale | Seth Gale |
 Andy ClydeStage Driver | Stage Driver |
 Roger ImhofMr. Crimmin | Mr. Crimmin |
| EEdmund EltonMr. Rutledge | Mr. Rutledge |
 Leona RobertsMrs. Rutledge | Mrs. Rutledge |
 Florence RobertsMrs. Bowling Green | Mrs. Bowling Green |
| GGeorge RosenerDr. Chandler | Dr. Chandler |
 Trevor BardetteJohn Hanks | John Hanks |
 Syd SaylorJohn Johnston | John Johnston |
 Elisabeth RisdonSarah Lincoln | Sarah Lincoln |
 Charles MiddletonTom Lincoln | Tom Lincoln |
 Alec CraigTrum Cogdall | Trum Cogdall |
 Erville AldersonStonewall Jackson (uncredited) | Stonewall Jackson (uncredited) |
 Ted BillingsOnlooker at Debate (uncredited) | Onlooker at Debate (uncredited) |
| HHenry BlairTad Lincoln (uncredited) | Tad Lincoln (uncredited) |
 Ed BradyRaft Steerer (uncredited) | Raft Steerer (uncredited) |
