As her Christmas Eve wedding draws near, Jennifer is visited by an angel and shown what could have been if she hadn't denied her true feelings for her childhood best friend.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nia FairweatherJennifer Ortiz | Jennifer Ortiz |
 Adriana DeMeoGabrielle Vernaci | Gabrielle Vernaci |
 Chris NothFather Kelly | Father Kelly |
 Otoja AbitDavid Wilks | David Wilks |
 Cooper KochAzrael Gabison | Azrael Gabison |
 David AnzueloMiguel Ortiz | Miguel Ortiz |
 Denny DillonJane Lally | Jane Lally |
| NNatasha GoodmanYoung Gabrielle | Young Gabrielle |
| CCamilla HardenYoung Jennifer | Young Jennifer |
 Tyra FerrellAlison Wilks | Alison Wilks |
 Tony D. HeadJeremy Wilks | Jeremy Wilks |
 Walker HareStoned Car Driver | Stoned Car Driver |
 Whitney Kimball LongRebecca Wilks | Rebecca Wilks |
 Avery WhittedVincent DiMarco | Vincent DiMarco |
 Joe PerrinoAnthony Vernaci | Anthony Vernaci |