In order to save her daytime soap drama from cancellation, head writer Maggie must convince Darin, fan favorite actor and her real-life ex-boyfriend, to return to the show.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jen LilleyMaggie | Maggie |
 Ryan PaeveyDarin Mitchell/Preston | Darin Mitchell/Preston |
 Serge HoudeWalter Fairchild | Walter Fairchild |
 Linda DanoAlice | Alice |
 Brittany MitchellGwen/Nicole | Gwen/Nicole |
 Jake FoyStewart/Chase | Stewart/Chase |
 Michele ScarabelliLucinda Fairchild/Sarah Gerard | Lucinda Fairchild/Sarah Gerard |
| Serge HoudeWalter Fairchild/Ted Gerard) | Walter Fairchild/Ted Gerard) |
 Latonya WilliamsTeri | Teri |
 Ryan JinnJohn | John |
 Cameron BancroftGregory James | Gregory James |
 Raugi YuMickey | Mickey |
| EEmily GiannozioTrudy/Lexi | Trudy/Lexi |
 Casey MandersonZak Peters | Zak Peters |
 Veronica LongRhonda | Rhonda |
| SSarah WhitneyFran | Fran |
 Robert UnderwoodJoey Buchanan | Joey Buchanan |
 Graeme DuffyKen | Ken |
| JJoe SutherlandTony | Tony |
| BBryceton CoteStage Manager | Stage Manager |