During World War II, Evie O'Connor, a secretary at Trojan Shirt Company, yearns for a tall, strong man to love her. When she slides an anonymous note into a shirt-pocket meant for a dashing man, oafish Edgar 'Wolf' Larson receives the shirt and disregards the letter. After hearing Evie's words, short and bumbling John McPherson writes back, claiming to be Wolf. But trouble arises when Evie asks to meet him in person.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Marsha HuntEvie O'Connor | Evie O'Connor |
 John CarrollEdgar "Wolf" Larson | Edgar "Wolf" Larson |
 Hume CronynJohn Phineas McPherson | John Phineas McPherson |
 Spring ByingtonMrs. McPherson | Mrs. McPherson |
 Pamela BrittonBarney Lee | Barney Lee |
 Norman LloydDeWitt Pynchon | DeWitt Pynchon |
| PPercival VivianMr. McPherson | Mr. McPherson |
 Donald CurtisCapt. Budlow | Capt. Budlow |
 Esther HowardMrs. Edgewaters | Mrs. Edgewaters |
 Robin RaymondEloise Edgewaters | Eloise Edgewaters |
| TTherese LyonMrs. Jackson | Mrs. Jackson |
| LLynn WhitneyMiss Jenkins | Miss Jenkins |
 Sonny LamontWire Walker (uncredited) | Wire Walker (uncredited) |