When an Amish woman's daughter is kidnapped, she seeks help from her estranged friend who left the Amish community and found social media stardom.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jorja CadenceLena Bieler | Lena Bieler |
 Elise BaumanSkye Kaufman | Skye Kaufman |
 Benjamin SutherlandAaron Bieler | Aaron Bieler |
 Allegra FultonMargaret Leigh | Margaret Leigh |
 Jamie ChampagneDeputy | Deputy |
 Devon MacDonaldRuth Ebersole | Ruth Ebersole |
| RRoger ShankDetective Fisk | Detective Fisk |
 Sam WexlerEddie Leigh | Eddie Leigh |
| MMichael ElleroC.J. | C.J. |
| RRyelyn CressmanMiriam Bieler | Miriam Bieler |
 David ThompsonCliff | Cliff |