Sophie writes a note to her aunt telling her that she is undecided whether she will marry Slippery Slim or Mustang Pete, but says she will accept the one who buys the best-looking horse.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Margaret JoslinSophie Clutts | Sophie Clutts |
 Victor PotelSlippery Slim | Slippery Slim |
 Harry ToddMustang Pete | Mustang Pete |
| EErnest Van PeltThe Deacon | The Deacon |