When Hope gives up on relationships and Christmas, it takes a Christmas miracle in the form of Charley to help mend her heart, trust again, realize the importance of family, and find love.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kelley JakleHope | Hope |
 Sean FarisNick | Nick |
 Bruce BoxleitnerRon | Ron |
 Lee MajorsCharley | Charley |
 Jake BuseySam | Sam |
 Kate VernonCaroline | Caroline |
 Tom VeraRyan | Ryan |
| SSarah Litton BurkettEmily | Emily |
 Larissa DaliMelody | Melody |
| CChristopher KauffmanChristmas Tree Dad | Christmas Tree Dad |
| EEmily WindoverChristmas Tree Mom | Christmas Tree Mom |
| KKarl Pietrzakextra (uncredited) | extra (uncredited) |