After Timmy Turner causes Santa amnesia he must become the new Santa in order to save Christmas.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Drake BellTimmy Turner | Timmy Turner |
 Daniella MonetTootie | Tootie |
 David James LewisDenzel Crocker | Denzel Crocker |
 Daran NorrisCosmo (voice) / Mr. Turner | Cosmo (voice) / Mr. Turner |
 Teryl RotheryMrs. Turner | Mrs. Turner |
 Devyn DaltonChristmas Carol | Christmas Carol |
 Tony CoxElmer | Elmer |
 Donavon StinsonSanta | Santa |
 Travis TurnerDingle Dave Elf (voice) | Dingle Dave Elf (voice) |
 Susanne BlakesleeWanda (voice) | Wanda (voice) |
 Tara StrongPoof (voice) | Poof (voice) |
 Butch HartmanGingers | Gingers |
| JJesse HaddockCrook #2 | Crook #2 |