A youth choir director needs to write a big song for the Christmas Eve show but finds herself distracted when a boy with a golden voice joins her choir, which will come as news to his widowed father.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kristin ChenowethKatherine Clark | Katherine Clark |
 Scott WolfGreg Scanton | Greg Scanton |
 Kevin G. QuinnDanny Scanton | Danny Scanton |
 Keith RobinsonBrian | Brian |
 Jennifer AspenJulie | Julie |
 Maria HowellCarol | Carol |
 Eric CloseShane | Shane |
 Scarlett BlumEmma | Emma |
 Lucia ScaranoIrene | Irene |
 Lacey KatenaMariah | Mariah |
| IIsabella Taylor FommeltNora | Nora |
| KKeyon Shammare Pickett, Jr.Scott | Scott |
| EEva AlbrightEmily | Emily |
| SStephen StarkweatherPete | Pete |
 Shanté DeLoachGwen | Gwen |
 Johanna JowettMariah’s Mom | Mariah’s Mom |
 Antoinette Lewis KingNew York Parkgoer | New York Parkgoer |