Holly Grant has learned a long time ago not to rely on Santa Claus leaving Mr. Right in her Christmas stocking. But Holly is in for a surprise when a handsome man arrives on her doorstep with a twinkle in his eye and Yuletide tree in tow.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kelli WilliamsHolly Grant | Holly Grant |
 Charles DurningSanta Claus | Santa Claus |
 Patrick MuldoonRyan Hayes | Ryan Hayes |
 Bruce ThomasTed Powell | Ted Powell |
 Shannon WilcoxJoanna Grant | Joanna Grant |
 Martin MullMartin Grant | Martin Grant |
 Bridget WhiteCarol Grant | Carol Grant |
 David StarzykIan | Ian |
| JJordan OrrNoah Grant | Noah Grant |
 Shane BaumelNeal Grant | Neal Grant |
 Erica GimpelBeth | Beth |
 Maeve QuinlanDiane | Diane |
| JJohn DybdahlStu | Stu |
| KKenneth DanzigerHarrison Lane | Harrison Lane |
 Rodger BumpassRussell Parker | Russell Parker |