 Sophia Cacciolacriminal mastermind (segment: "Poisoned") | criminal mastermind (segment: "Poisoned") |
 Michael J. Epsteinsafe cracker (segment: "Poisoned") | safe cracker (segment: "Poisoned") |
 Lara Jean SullivanLJ (segment: The Dance Party Massacre) | LJ (segment: The Dance Party Massacre) |
| SStabatha La ThrillsRaver (segment: "What are We even gonna do with all these Bodies, kid?") | Raver (segment: "What are We even gonna do with all these Bodies, kid?") |
 Glenn BerggoetzThe Entity (segment "Very Sane") | The Entity (segment "Very Sane") |
 Luc BernierMan (segment "Failed Suicide Attempt") | Man (segment "Failed Suicide Attempt") |
| JJohn BrownTom | Tom |
| MMark Gordon BuckleyHusband (segment: "Come Find Me") | Husband (segment: "Come Find Me") |
| JJustin CavellBand Member (segment "Wrestlemassacre") | Band Member (segment "Wrestlemassacre") |
 Shawn BurkettMike (segment Room 125) | Mike (segment Room 125) |
| DDavid BusboomThe Masked God (segment "Divination") | The Masked God (segment "Divination") |
 Charles ChudabalaJudge (segment: The Dance Party Massacre) | Judge (segment: The Dance Party Massacre) |
| DDavid John ClarkCourier (segment: "Special Delivery") | Courier (segment: "Special Delivery") |
| YYlenia Crosta MancinThe mother (segment "The Basement" | The mother (segment "The Basement" |
| DDave DeFabrizioEdgar (segment: Welcome) | Edgar (segment: Welcome) |
| JJordan FerraroDr. Annie Cula (The Dentist) | Dr. Annie Cula (The Dentist) |
| FFaith FlintThe Wife (segment: Stitched Up) | The Wife (segment: Stitched Up) |
| MMaya GraceGirl (segment "Very Sane") | Girl (segment "Very Sane") |
 Tom GoreMotorcycle Mike (Frozen) | Motorcycle Mike (Frozen) |
| JJuliana GlinkStudent (segment "Good / Evil") | Student (segment "Good / Evil") |
 Donna HamblinWife (segment: "Come Find Me") | Wife (segment: "Come Find Me") |
| PPhil HamerJoseph Alexander (segment: "Two Ghost Tent") | Joseph Alexander (segment: "Two Ghost Tent") |
| TTony HamerThe Ghost (segment: "Two Ghost Tent") | The Ghost (segment: "Two Ghost Tent") |
| TTimmy HawkinsThe Priest (segment: "Special Delivery") | The Priest (segment: "Special Delivery") |
| KKailee HellerGoblin (The Dentist) | Goblin (The Dentist) |
| AAyse HowardBetsy (segment Room 125) | Betsy (segment Room 125) |
| CCatherine HoareJane | Jane |
 Michael HowardHigh Priest of Imhotnka (segment "The Summoning") | High Priest of Imhotnka (segment "The Summoning") |
| SShayna JalieghDaisy (segment Girl Bye) | Daisy (segment Girl Bye) |
| KKatherine Kirby-ParkerWaiting room lady (The Dentist) | Waiting room lady (The Dentist) |
