Father Paul has to judge a hymn writing contest,of which his friend Father Tom really wants to win. Meanwhile Father Paul has to help his church members with confessions. Released as apart of 2010's New York Television Festival.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Frank ConniffFrank Conniff | Frank Conniff |
 Bobcat GoldthwaitBishop GoldThwarp | Bishop GoldThwarp |
 Tom KennyFather Tom | Father Tom |
 Karen KilgariffKaren Kilgariff | Karen Kilgariff |
 Eddie PepitoneEddie Pepitone | Eddie Pepitone |
 Mary Lynn RajskubMary Lynn Rajskub | Mary Lynn Rajskub |
| DDavid Earl WatermanDavid Earl Waterman | David Earl Waterman |