Melanie, an investigative journalist, becomes obsessed with a string of disappearances in Lemon Creek. As she digs into the history of the disappearances, she remains dangerously unaware that the culprit is her own sister, Emma.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Beatrice BoeppleBethany | Bethany |
 Beth MetcalfMelanie | Melanie |
 Jessy WintersNot listed | Not listed |
 Kelsey RheaJenna | Jenna |
| HHeidi MikacEmma | Emma |
| KKyler ErnstHannah Jones | Hannah Jones |
| SShy HunterKeshia Clemons | Keshia Clemons |
| JJessie MaudlinKaren | Karen |