Sarah is a devout Amish woman who suspects foul play after her sister, Ida, dies in a mysterious barn fire. Driven to protect her young nephew, Sarah begins investigating her brother-in-law.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jean-Luc BilodeauEli Stutzman | Eli Stutzman |
 Maddy HillisSarah Gingerich | Sarah Gingerich |
 Karis CameronIda Gingerich | Ida Gingerich |
 Sean DepnerJacob Miller | Jacob Miller |
 Francisca DennisCandy | Candy |
 Gwynyth WalshRebecca Stutzman | Rebecca Stutzman |
 Kwesi AmeyawDetective Matthews | Detective Matthews |
 Patch MayGlen Pritchett | Glen Pritchett |
 Dean Paul GibsonMinister Stutzman | Minister Stutzman |