Three inmates from completely different backgrounds are granted one final opportunity to appeal their cases not to a judge, but to America. Their freedom depends on a live public vote, and as their stories unexpectedly intertwine, the show exposes how differently we judge guilt, innocence and redemption depending on who's standing in front of us.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tobias TruvillionMalik Carter | Malik Carter |
 Ronni HawkSofia Reyes | Sofia Reyes |
 Jacob KaufmanEvan Whitmore | Evan Whitmore |
 Jeff MeachamJerry Mander | Jerry Mander |
 Steve BlanchardCharles Whitmore | Charles Whitmore |
| MMiko DeFoorWarden Haskell | Warden Haskell |
| DDanielle GrossKelly Morgan | Kelly Morgan |
 Johnell YoungMarcus Reed | Marcus Reed |
| AAshley AustinStephanie | Stephanie |
| TTamarriceAudience Member | Audience Member |