They are the closest of friends and forever pals,and best of all; these dads don't need any gals in My Dads Butt Buddies 2! They are best butt buddies with all gay, hardcore benefits.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Chance Taylor(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Jesus De Leon(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Joey Lexington(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Kent Burke(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Marshall O. Boy(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Neil Evans(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Paul Carrigan(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
| RRiley Duval(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Steven Richards(archive footage) | (archive footage) |
 Super Frank(archive footage) | (archive footage) |