The Baby-sitters holiday party promises to be the best ever! But why isn't Stacey sharing in all of the fun? Find out why this is truly a special Christmas for the Baby-sitters Club!
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Meghan AndrewsMallory Pike | Mallory Pike |
| MMelissa ChasseDawn Schafer | Dawn Schafer |
| JJeni F. WinslowClaudia Kishi | Claudia Kishi |
| AAvriel HillmanKristy Thomas | Kristy Thomas |
 Meghan LaheyMary Anne Spier | Mary Anne Spier |
| NNicolle RochelleJessi Ramsey | Jessi Ramsey |
| JJessica PrunellStacey McGill | Stacey McGill |
 Danny TamberelliJackie Rodowsky | Jackie Rodowsky |